About Technique Critique

Sample public critiques

A selection of real questions players have brought to the instructor team.

Am I on the right track?

I’ve watched through the primer and tried out some of the ideas. I think I had a zero picking angle before. I’m trying usx, although dsx feels ok too. It’s helped me jump up a fair bit in speed when changing strings. But doing the malmstein 6 pattern and straight pentatonic 2 per string I am much slower than I can tremolo. I think some of it is left hand speed, but also changing string cleanly and quickly, especially on the 2 per string pentatonic scale, I can’t get those speeds. I’m wondering if I’m on the right tracks and just need to practice more. Or if I’m doing something wrong. I’d love to be able to play Angus young/ Hendrix/SRV fast stuff to speed. Thank you!

Player
TTedsu
Status
open
Privacy
Public
Last Activity:
View critique

Further attempts at sorting out best motion

This is really a follow on to the earlier technique critique at https://troygrady.com/dashboard/tc/495/ although that technique critique was closed before I had time to upload the requested videos. (So it may be worth referring to the old critique to see what has been done before, especially if a new instructor does this critique. It was possibly worth starting with a fresh critique, anyway, since there were a lot of picking related videos on the earlier part of that critique as well). So I have videoed the EVH-style and Di Meola-style tap tests for the longer time and without a metronome. Also, using a mouse wrist rest as discussed on the earlier technique critique. I've also uploaded a new video of the elbow tap test. (Videos of the other two motion tests are on the earlier technique critique; but for a relatively short duration and with a metronome.). Anyway, still trying to sort out my best motion as I was in the latter part of the earlier technique critique? Also, I have another question - is it useful to practise these motions much - apart from the occasional video to upload? I think it was suggested the motions are fairly basic to avoid some of the other complexities with picking and guitar playing, and are normally fairly easy for anybody. On the other hand, I think Troy suggested that he had found practising the forearm motion away from the guitar to be useful. (This feels fairly abstracted from actual guitar playing at this point which I would quite like to get back to.)

Status
open
Privacy
Public
Last Activity:
View critique

Garage spikes

I've been playing for about a year now, and garage spikes have always plagued my alternate picking. Recently, I've started making a more focused effort of identifying and fixing this problem. I made some observations on my own, while I was waiting for my Magnet to arrive. I've boiled the problem down to how I hold my pick, since I'm pretty sure I'm doing the RDT motion correctly. I noticed my pick grip naturally produces a slight downward slant, so I began nudging it between my fingers, tilting it the other way. By doing this, I actually managed to produce garage spikes on the downstrokes, instead of the upstrokes. (It makes sense that upstroke garage spikes are more common, since the arm is slightly supinated for tall mouse advantage.) Fiddling around some more, I could get the pick into a position where upstrokes and downstrokes felt very similar in terms of smoothness. The problem is, this pick grip is very, very specific, and even a slight tilt in either direction produces spikes. When I pick up the pick and try to get it roughly into position, chances are it won't be in the correct position, and so I have to fiddle with it a lot before beginning to play. Try to tremolo, nudge pick, repeat. I feels like there is no there is no major difference between the right grip, and the wrong grip, and that even a few degrees of slant angle either way can produce spikes. I'm trying not to hold the pick too tightly, I use edge picking, and I even use a positive pick point, since it seems to help somewhat. It's also important to mention, that, from my experience, any slant coming from my forearm won't effect garage spikes. If I manage to get a spike-less grip at a zero degree slant, I also get smooth picking when doing DWPS. I'm also comfortable tremolo picking from my elbow, but the spike situation is the same. I uploaded 2 videos of me tremolo picking on the G string, one where I get spikes, and one where I don't. Only the difference is that I happened to pick up the pick slightly differently. (At least I'm not seeing any obvious difference.) I also uploaded two palm muted tremolos, one on the E, and one on the A string, since I'm also struggling with that. This whole situation leaves my confused, and I'm left to wonder if anything else is contributing to garage spikes, other than my pick grip, or there is a fundamental problem with my pick grip that I'm not noticing.

Player
VVilmos
Lesson
Pick Grip
Status
open
Privacy
Public
Last Activity:
View critique

Stuck with slow speed and tension 2NPS

Hello, I worked on improving picking speed earlier this year with some success but I’m still stuck when it comes to 2NPS. I develop tension and what feels like string hopping with garage spikes and can’t seem to shake it. The speed is quite slow. Would appreciate any advice. Thx

Player
DDFH
Status
open
Privacy
Public
Last Activity:
View critique

Technique Critique #2: Applying the Chosen Motion to Musical Phrases

This critique follows on from the previous TC, where the focus was identifying and refining a primary picking motion. The emphasis now shifts to applying that motion to a wider range of musical phrases while continuing to improve pick attack, smoothness, accuracy, and overall consistency. This critique will track progress as the motion becomes more natural and functional in real playing situations.

Player
MMickeyT9
Status
open
Privacy
Public
Last Activity:
View critique

Still working on smooth DSX motion.

So, here I am again. Trying to get a smooth dsx motion working. I have tried all the setups, all the grips, looked through all tutorials and everything. Still I always get stuck on the upstroke. It's like It's always to vertical and spikey. Also I often end up making a curve instead of a straight line.

Status
open
Privacy
Public
Last Activity:
View critique

String switching back and forth with (attempting) the tall mouse USX RDT technique covered in chapter 11

Hi, I am having a lot of issues with string changing, particularly with the USX tall mouse picking style covered in chapter 11. I can basically do it (I think) on single strings okay, but feel things get trapped while I'm playing in the examples, and put in more effort than I should really need. I'd be curious to see how close my motions are to the optimal technique, as well as what steps you would recommend to improve, and particularly chapters that may be of particular use to me here.

Status
closed
Privacy
Public
Last Activity:
View critique

First TC

Hi, this is my first critique! I’ve been a Masters in Mechanics member since last December and have been working on developing upstroke escape mechanics (USX), with Eric Johnson’s music/style as my long-term goal. The two videos are descending cascading pentatonic sequences at the 12th fret, both at 150 bpm (16th notes): the 6’s pattern, and the 5’s pattern with the sweep on the 5th note. For starters I’m not chasing one specific problem. I’d appreciate a general evaluation of my mechanics at this tempo and your advice on what to prioritize to play faster and cleaner. I’d also welcome any thoughts on whether my pickslant and escapes are set up correctly for these patterns, and how the sweep is working in the 5’s pattern. Thanks for taking the time to look at this!

Player
Jjphys
Status
closed
Privacy
Public
Last Activity:
View critique

Taking the Motion Tests

Hi! I'm Iñaki and I'm just getting started with this whole journey. I've played guitar for many years, and I've always struggled with alternate picking speed. I feel it's what's held me back the most. Many times I had doubted whether I could be physically incapable of playing fast alternate picking, but through taking these tests I've confirmed that I am not, and have a lot of room to grow. Just wanted to upload these videos so as to know if there might be any things that I could be doing wrong in some of these motions. I would really appreciate any feedback! Thank you! Send you a big hug from Argentina!

Status
open
Privacy
Public
Last Activity:
View critique

DSX 2WPS -> DBX

Hi, this is a continuation of https://troygrady.com/users/jfo/tc/614/ I'm really committed to working on this goal this winter. I've been concentrating on making my primary motion wrist based instead of forearm based and I feel a lot more comfortable with that, and overall it feels like a much more controlled and stable technique than what I used before. I can feel that upward escapes are within reach here. I'd like to focus on incorporating that with the goal of moving towards a DBX semi-circular motion that will let me play up tempo bluegrass crosspicking eventually, so in other words, the main thing I need guidance on here is how to move forward with the base technique in the video in a way that unlocks (or at least doesn't block) up tempo crosspicking in a bluegrass style. Previous TC was really helpful, just starting a new one to have a new place to keep track. Please let me know what to do next! Thanks a lot.

Player
Jjfo
Status
open
Privacy
Public
Last Activity:
View critique
Complete public directory

Browse more with a free account

You are viewing a selection of public Technique Critiques. Create a free account to browse the complete public directory. Some instructor feedback and discussion require a paid membership.